Author Topic: Press releases and news stories often contain exaggerated claims  (Read 78 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline agate

  • Administrator
  • *****
  • Posts: 9822
  • MS diagnosed 1980
  • Location: Pacific Northwest
From NEJM Journal Watch, December 23, 2015:

Quote
Press Releases and News Stories Often Contain Exaggerated Claims

Paul S. Mueller, MD, MPH, FACP reviewing Sumner P et al. BMJ 2014 Dec 10.

Explicit claims often are reported that are not backed up by corresponding peer-reviewed research articles.

Healthcare institutions use press releases to convey the results of research studies to news media; however, some press releases exaggerate findings and lack appropriate caveats. In this study, researchers determined how often press releases and news stories contained claims and advice that distorted or exaggerated those presented in corresponding peer-reviewed original research articles.

The researchers identified 462 press releases issued in 2011 by 20 leading U.K. universities, the press releases' associated peer-reviewed research articles, and 688 related print and online news stories. Forty percent of press releases contained more direct or explicit advice than the associated journal articles did. The odds of exaggerated advice in a news story were seven times higher when the press release also contained exaggerated advice than when it did not. For correlational results, one third of press releases were more deterministic (causal) than the associated research articles. For nonhuman studies, one third of press releases contained inflated claims regarding implications for humans. However, the presence of exaggeration in press releases was not associated with a greater number of related news stories.

COMMENT

In this study, many press releases issued by healthcare institutions contained claims and advice that exceeded those presented in corresponding peer-reviewed original articles. Furthermore, exaggeration in print and online news stories was associated with exaggeration in press releases. These results are important, because news stories influence the healthcare-related behaviors not only of patients, but also of healthcare providers. Obviously, neither patients nor physicians should rely solely on news media for healthcare information.

 
CITATION(S):

Sumner P et al. The association between exaggeration in health related science news and academic press releases: Retrospective observational study. BMJ 2014 Dec 10; 349:g7015.

The entire BMJ article can be seen here.
MS Speaks--online for 17 years

SPMS, diagnosed 1980. Avonex 2001-2004. Copaxone 2007-2010. Glatopa (glatiramer acetate 40mg 3 times/week) since 12/16/20.